[Loftus] is insisting on adopting a viewpoint that no religious person need adopt nor does adopt when dealing with other religions. At this point, this clearly becomes a normative claim: we ought to adopt a methodological naturalist stance in determine which religion is the right one.
But this clashes with his own definition of religion. He insists in a number of places that what makes religion religion is its link to the supernatural. So every religion that is properly called a religion makes supernatural claims. What Loftus want to do here, then, is start with the assumption not merely that the religion has the burden of proof — that’s his first point — but that the religion is wrong. … [H]e’s building in a structure that forces us to assume that the central defining feature of any religion is actually expressing something that is not true. I can’t see how you could possibly have a fair test that doesn’t merely ask you to consider that it might be false, but also to assume it false.
ARCHIVES: Lasciate ogne speranza…
- Follow FideCogitActio : "Omnis per gratiam" fidescogitactio @ gmail . com on WordPress.com
This just out…
Top Posts & Pages
- The Emmaus Pope...
- Novena of the Holy Face of Jesus - Day 1
- Favorite Quotations & Resources (online)
- What do you mean by "FrankenMass"?
- An "Eastern Papist" Florilegium
- "You may not be interested in the dialectic..."
- Wash up, time to eat! My latest at OnePeterFive.com - @OnePeterFive
- Patron Saints & Other Guides
PAST CODGITATIONS… lost in space but not time
Tag, you’re it!#YOPO Advent Americanism Aristotle atheism bloggorhea blogorrhea Catholic Church Catholic Ents Catholicism WOW! Catholic Social Teaching Christ Christianity Christmas culchure demographics devotion do a barrel roll economics exile God grace and truth Haurietis aquas hermeneutic of ambiguity history honey badger pope hope and change humor Invisible Catholic Jesus Keefe Kulturkrampf Lent liturgy logic marriage memoirs movies Neo-Jesuits Neo-Theodrome news of the weird not-so-solemn nonsense novena Our Francis of the Interviews papal midrash Philosophy Pius XII Pope Francis prayer quotations Sacred Heart Second Vatican Conch Shell Septuagesima soft ultramontanism solemn nonsense SSM The Catholic Thing The Francis Affect the Friends of Francis Effect The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass the Incarnation the Mass the medium is the message the normalcy bias theology The Sacred Heart This is Denzinger This isn't Denzinger This is why we can't have nice things Thomas Aquinas Tradition truthiness truth is the best ecumenism words ¡Hagan lío!
Halt! Who goes there?
Who are these people?
- 229,560 hits